Quick answer: below are two complete Task 2 essays answering the same question. One sits around band 6, one around band 8, by my estimate against the official criteria. The difference between them is not vocabulary fireworks. It is a position that holds from the first line to the last, ideas that are developed instead of listed, cohesion that flows without linker machinery, and errors rare enough to stop being a texture.
Every sample essay page on the internet shows you a band 9 and says write like this. That teaches you about as much as watching a great driver teaches you to drive. What teaches is contrast: the same question answered at two levels, with the reasons named.
The question
In many countries, people buy new clothes frequently and throw away clothes they have worn only a few times. Why is this happening? What can be done to reduce this problem?
A two part question: a why and a what can be done. Remember the trap that eats this type: answering only half. Both essays below answer both parts, one thinly and one properly.
Essay A, around band 6, my estimate
These days, many people purchase new clothes very often and throw them away after wearing them few times. This essay will discuss the reasons of this problem and suggest some solutions.
Firstly, the main reason is that clothes are very cheap nowadays. Many shops sell fashion at low prices, so people can buy many clothes easily. Secondly, fashion changes very quickly. People see new styles on social media and they want to buy them. Moreover, some people think that wearing old clothes is not good for their image, so they always buy new ones.
There are some solutions for this problem. Firstly, the government should make campaigns to tell people about the environment. Secondly, companies should make clothes with better quality, so people can wear them for long time. In addition, people can give their old clothes to charity instead of throwing them. Also, schools can teach children about this problem.
In conclusion, people throw away clothes because fashion is cheap and changes fast. The government, companies and people should work together to solve this problem.
- Task Response. Both parts are answered, which saves it, but every idea is named and abandoned in one sentence. Why do cheap clothes cause throwing away? The essay never says. Ideas are listed, not developed, and that alone holds it near 6.
- Coherence and Cohesion. You can hear the machinery: Firstly, Secondly, Moreover, In addition, Also. Five linkers carrying no logic of their own.
- Lexical Resource. Safe and repetitive. Buy new clothes and throw away recycle through the whole essay. Nothing is wrong, and nothing is precise.
- Grammar. Mostly accurate simple sentences with the classic slips, few times for a few times, reasons of, for long time. Range is narrow, so there is little to reward.
Essay B, around band 8, my estimate
In much of the world, clothing has quietly become disposable: bought in bulk, worn briefly, and discarded. This essay argues that the habit is driven mainly by the collapse in clothing prices and by social media fashion cycles, and that the most realistic responses lie with consumers and regulation rather than goodwill.
The first driver is price. When a shirt costs less than a meal, replacing it feels more rational than washing, repairing or even storing it, and retailers have built entire business models on that calculation. The second driver is speed. Trends that once changed each season now change weekly online, and a wardrobe that was fashionable in March can feel embarrassing by May. Crucially, these two forces feed each other: low prices make it painless to chase trends, and fast trends justify constant buying.
Solutions need to match the causes rather than simply sound virtuous. Awareness campaigns, the standard suggestion, change little when the economics still reward waste. Pricing is a stronger lever: small taxes on ultra cheap garments, or rules requiring retailers to fund textile recycling, would make disposability visible at the till. Alongside regulation, resale platforms have already shown that behaviour shifts when the alternative is convenient, since selling a worn jacket in minutes turns yesterday’s waste into today’s small income.
In short, disposable fashion is a predictable response to cheap prices and accelerating trends, and it will fade only when the incentives change. Policies that price in the waste, supported by convenient resale, offer more than posters ever will.
- Task Response. Both parts answered and developed. Each cause gets a mechanism, not just a name, and the solutions are weighed against each other, which is what well developed actually means.
- Coherence and Cohesion. Almost no visible linkers, and yet nothing is hard to follow, because the logic itself connects the sentences. “Crucially, these two forces feed each other” is cohesion doing real work.
- Lexical Resource. Precise, natural choices: disposable, visible at the till, price in the waste. No forced academic costume, and that is the point.
- Grammar. Wide range, controlled. Errors are rare enough that the examiner stops noticing them, which is the practical meaning of band 8 accuracy.
What the two bands are made of
| Criterion | The band 6 habit | The band 8 habit |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | Names ideas, moves on | Explains the mechanism behind each idea |
| Coherence | Linkers carry the essay | Logic carries the essay |
| Vocabulary | Safe words, recycled | Precise words, placed once |
| Grammar | Accurate but narrow | Wide and controlled |
Read this line twice: nothing in the band 8 essay is a word you do not know. The two extra bands are built from development and control, not from vocabulary you have never seen. That is why they are learnable.
How to use this pair
Write your own answer to the question above before reading either essay again. Then mark yourself with the table, one criterion at a time, against the official descriptors. Your cheapest band is hiding in whichever column sounds most like you.
The course is open · $225 once
The complete IELTS course by Dr. Nasir
42 days. 47 masterclasses. 32 full papers, marked, with a written explanation on every single question. Academic and General Training are both inside, tagged day by day, and the whole thing is built for the computer test. One payment, lifetime access, no subscription.
The entire 42 day syllabus is printed on that page before you pay anything. Taught by a practising doctor with a verified IELTS band 8.5, CEFR C2.
The three questions everyone asks
Are these real exam essays? No, and nobody honest publishes those. Both were written for this page against the official criteria, and the bands are my professional estimates, labelled as estimates.
Should I memorise the band 8 essay? No, and the marking rules are brutal about it. A totally memorised answer is one of the three conditions that score Band 0. Learn its habits, never its sentences.
Why not show a band 9? Because contrast teaches and perfection does not. The distance between where you are and band 8 is a set of habits you can name. The distance to a band 9 showpiece is just discouraging.
About the author
Dr. Nasir Bukhari is the Executive Director of CliniVerba and a practising doctor (MBBS). He sat IELTS himself and scored an overall band 8.5, CEFR level C2, with a perfect 9.0 in Reading, 8.5 in Listening and 8.0 in both Writing and Speaking. The report form is on his About page. He is certified in all four skills by OET’s Head of Education and has taught in more than 40 countries. More about Dr. Nasir.